Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors
Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors

Etihad Stadium attendance under spotlight as 12,000 seats appeared empty for Man City vs Brighton

Etihad Stadium attendance under spotlight as 12,000 seats appeared empty for Man City vs Brighton
View inside the Etihad before Man City vs Brighton - Photo via IMAGO / Focus Images

Manchester City’s official attendance for their Carabao Cup win over Brighton & Hove Albion has been subject to conflicting claims, with the club reporting a new domestic-cup record at the Etihad Stadium.

Major transport disruption in Manchester added further context to the debate over the apparently empty seats.

Man City attendance conflict amid major travel disruption

City’s post-match report put the crowd at 55,343, a new domestic-cup record at the Etihad, surpassing the previous mark of 53,356 against Burnley in January 2018.

The BBC listed 49,107, while others reported similar figures just over 49,000 and estimated around 12,000 empty seats. The 6,000-plus difference leaves the precise attendance unclear.

Despite the gaps in the stands, those who attended witnessed a closely contested encounter.

Brighton twice took the lead through Malick Yalcouye and Georginio Rutter, while Mateo Kovacic equalised for City before Vitor Reis forced a penalty shootout with a late deflected effort.

City goalkeeper Geronimo Rulli then proved decisive, saving from Yasin Ayari before denying Seagulls captain Lewis Dunk in sudden death to secure his side’s progression to the quarter-finals.

TfGM had suspended tram services on the Altrincham, Trafford Park and Eccles lines between October 19th and November 1st, while Airport and East Didsbury services were reduced. City advertised replacement shuttle buses between Altrincham and the Etihad.

A burst water main also closed Portland Street and Piccadilly Gardens bus station, with numerous bus services diverted. TfGM also warned disruption would continue throughout the evening and advised supporters travelling to the match to allow extra time.

This confirms fans faced difficulties reaching the stadium, and it was even noted that some supporters were still arriving at their seats by half-time.

However, there is no independent confirmation of how many were delayed or whether this explains the difference between the attendance figures.

FGG says: Etihad’s empty seats remain an unwanted talking point

A crowd of more than 49,000 would still be sizeable, but City’s higher figure changes the picture considerably.

Until the difference between 55,343 and 49,107 is explained, neither the new-record claim nor the estimate of 12,000 empty seats should be treated as completely settled.

The travel disruption also deserves consideration, as it does not prove thousands were held up until half-time, but the empty seats should not automatically be interpreted as supporters choosing to stay away from another midweek encounter.

Lewis joined as News and Features Editor in July 2025, having previously held senior roles at Snack Media and GRV Media. A passionate follower of sport, in particular football and golf, as well as a proud Aldershot Town supporter, he brings over six years of experience in the digital sports publishing space.

Articles: 1593